critical analysis in social work

AuthorLeave a comment

Note the difference between good descriptive writing and good critical analysis. This forum should also provide a safe place for social workers to reflect on … This critical commentary focuses on social work ethics as an emerging subject area within the professional discipline of social work. What I like about the book is that it covers the core skills of critical thinking, critical writing and critical reflection. Hussain et al. GROUP EXERCISE – THE TRIAL! Examples of critical analysis based on assignments from Level 6 students in the School of Health and Social Work. Figures from the National Institute of Excellence (2016) and from National Statistics (2014) indicate that more women than men required treatment for mental ill health conditions, with 1 in 4 women compared to 1 in 10 men diagnosed with depression. A critical analysis of the social work definition according to the relational paradigm. Must read for students on professional courses. According to ABS statistics, it affects up to 105,000 Australian every year. CRITICAL REFLECTION AND ANALYSIS - Apply critical reflection and analysis to inform and provide a rationale for professional decision-making Social workers critically reflect on their practice, use analysis, apply professional judgement and reasoned discernment. Social Work Thories. This according to Thompson (2000: 35) "gives a framework for analysing the situation and generating a number of possible options". An exploration of counselling as a form of social work practice and how it is influenced by the critical social work approach will be included. A degree of scepticism about existing knowledge, beliefs and values. To critically analyse means to make a judgement about the quality of evidence and include when it can and can’t support your argument. 5. A very helpful text for those entering social work training in all of the different formats - will be particularly useful for those on apprenticeship programmes applying theory directly to practice. Thought provoking, humane and grounded. Really thorough book covering a comprehensive insight into critical thinking and analysis. Please refer to our updated inspection copy policy for details. See our resources page for information, support and best practices. Overall, this is an excellent book which is memorable for its fusion of concepts with sheer practicality, no jargon, no acronyms, just clear language and sharp analysis. Muller et al. The sample may also display some selection bias as the participants were offered academic reward if they completed the retention tests. This highly practical guidebook will help you develop the critical and analytical skills essential to your successful social work education and evidence-informed, reflective practice. If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. The main concern in evaluating a case study is to accurately assess its quality and ultimately to offer clients social work interventions informed by the ... research design, data collection, and data analysis. Within the supervisory environment, social workers should have the opportunity to critically analyse their knowledge, values and skills and their understanding of the work they are undertaking. Excellent Paper Example 2. 1 In this context, I am using the term ‘social work ethics’ as a singular term to refer to a specialist area of professional ethics comprising the study of the norms of right action, good qualities of character and values relating to the nature of the good life that are aspired to, … Profession specific examples of critical analysis in writing Examples of critical analysis based on assignments from Level 6 students in the School of Health and Social Work. Therefore, according to the critical theory, the aim of social work is to emancipate people from oppression and allow a critique of the ideology of "operativity", State law and governance. This book provides a critical analysis of evidence-based practice in social work. The National Institute for Clinical Excellence (2016) states that 1 in 4 women will suffer from depression compared with 1 in 10 men. It will then provide an analysis of the political, cultural and social contexts that shape practice in relation to risk management. However, this research only measured known diagnosed cases. We identify, evaluate and integrate multiple sources of knowledge and evidence. 6. Each component, the event, the political arena and the bureaucracy and adhocracy, have processes, actors and dependencies the … As social workers bring a unique perspective, diverse types of evidence and model of working, they have an ethical obligation to base their professional judgement on the synthesis of well-researched empirical evidence. Professor of Social Work and Social Policy, Isabel Martin, Independent Practice Teacher, Argyll and Bute, Scotland, Faculty of Health, Social Care and Education, Kingston University, school of Psychological Social & Behavioural Sciencs, Coventry University, School of Social Work, Kingston University, Faculty Of Health And Social Care, Anglia Ruskin University, Department of Sociological Studies, Sheffield University, Due to the current restrictions in place, our inspection copy policy has changed. Ultimately critical thinking and analysis plays an important role in improving outcomes for the children and families that social workers work with. Buy Applying Critical Thinking and Analysis in Social Work 1 by Rogers, Michaela, Allen, Dan (ISBN: 9781526436580) from Amazon's Book Store. (2017) inform us that the male suicide rate is twice as high in the UK and six times more likely in the US compared to suicide rates for women. It has excellent content and practice relevant exercises with which to encourage students to develop their critical thinking further both in their academic studies and professional practice. April 2019 | 208 pages | SAGE Publications Ltd, Part I: An Introduction to Critical Thinking and Analysis, Chapter 1: Introduction to Critical thinking, Chapter 2: Introduction to Critical Knowledge, Part II: An Introduction to Critical Reading and Writing, Part III: Critical Thinking and Analysis in Practice, Chapter 6: Professional Judgement and Decision Making, Chapter 7: Critical Analysis and Working with Risks and Strengths, Chapter 9: Analytical Assessments and Report Writing, Dean of Lincoln Academy of Learning and Teaching, University of Lincoln, Senior Lecturer Applied Social Studies and Social Work, The University of Sunderland, Graham Ixer. Furthermore, Soneji et al. An excellent resource when introducing youth justice to social work students. Hello, would you like to continue browsing the SAGE website? Updated February 12, 2020 In composition, critical analysis is a careful examination and evaluation of a text, image, or other work or performance. Social work has grown and developed from the seed that is envelops social issues in our society. Critical incident analysis has developed as a tool to aid critical reflection in practice, in health and social work. The sample used was a volunteer sample; this is considered a weak form of sampling as the participants are self-selected and convenient (Alonzo, 2017). Due to the current restrictions in place, our inspection copy policy has changed. This book provides highly practical suggestions for record keeping and report writing, the good practice of which frequently slips from attention and is fraught with pitfalls. However, Muller et al. It allows you to turn experiences into learning that you can then use to improve your practice. This highly practical guidebook will help you develop the critical and analytical skills essential to your successful social work education and evidence-informed, reflective practice. A range of models are clearly set out by the authors for students to follow, including helpful themes such as ‘danger points’ which alert students to some of the pitfalls in certain models of thinking. These examples are for illustration only and should not be copied. As the authors of this book suggest, critical thinking is a ‘sought after’ skill in social work practice, yet is something that can be difficult for students to conceptualise. ‘A new model for social work reflection: whatever the weather’ Professional Social Work, March, pp28-29. Critical thinking in social work means that you are able to look at a person or situation from an objective and neutral standpoint, without jumping to conclusions or making assumptions. It introduces readers to the fast changing research, policy, legislative, and practice context. A really helpful addition to the social work literature. In social work, critical practice is crucial because social work is a nexus where social contradictions are manifest. I therefore recommend this book be used by student social workers throughout their social work degrees to help them develop and master their skills. Fabio Folgheraiter and Maria Luisa Raineri. These contradictions are at work inside our subjectivity every day — it is not an exaggeration to say that our practice is at the mercy of contradictory forces. Critically explore and apply the values, ethics & diversity underpinning professional social work practice. New words for essays in Critical social work analysis essay examples. Following this, a critical appreciation of the concept of risk decision making will be considered. The purpose of this Special Critical Commentary is to provide a personal review of changes in social work, primarily in England, over the last forty years and to reflect on how my own ideas have developed. It is possible that men find other ways of coping without professional help and remain unaccounted for in these statistics as other sources (National Statistics, 2016) indicated that 80% of people dependent upon alcohol were male. It is the account of the social forces of domination that takes its theoretical activity to … Critical Analysis Paper #1 Question #1: Social Work and Systems Theory Social Work as a concept and a career is simple, yet difficult to define. Also, please note that the citations are fictitious. This may indicate that men use alcohol as a form of self-medication (Wong, 2018). Apply critical reflection and analysis to consider the complex interplay of variables that shape the social work role and task, and provide a rationale for professional decision making. An awareness of the social … This may lead to an increased uptake by students looking to achieve high grades or those currently achieving low grades who wish to improve. These theories differ in their approach to solving social problems. Selection bias is a common problem in studies where the participants are self-selecting (Baker, 2018). Homelessness is a major social problem in Australia. (2016) seek to maintain consistency in their sample by using consecutive cohorts of second-year students who would be expected to have similar levels of knowledge. This practical text is written in such a way, that it aims to speak directly to student social workers to help them understand the concept, and application of, critical thinking. 5/3/13 Social Work Theories Social Work Theories A social work theory provides an objective analysis of problems experienced by a society and the theoretical basis for various practices that are aimed towards dealing with them. Therefore,  the sample may not be representative of the entire student population (Ahmed et al., 2014). This book is a very valuable and rich resource to enable social work students in training to develop effective critical thinking skills and habits. Applying critical theory to social work practice fits well with the professional values of enhancement of people's well-being, promotion of social justice, and empowerment of … (2016) present a prospective randomised trial identifying that ECG interpretation skills within a cohort of medical students declined rapidly after initial teaching regardless of the method of teaching. (2018) explain that symptoms normally display themselves in the same way whether a person is male or female, adding that the most common symptoms are poor mood, lethargy, poor appetite, lack of enthusiasm and poor sleep pattern. Master of Social Work Critical Analysis The primary objective of the MSW: Critical Analysis of Social Work is to provide opportunities for students to develop knowledge and skills necessary for the critical analysis of social work, and to examine the challenges and possibilities of working toward more inclusive and just policies and practices in the future. M.S.W. Critical reflection is an essential part of continuous learning and development. It is problematic to accurately measure whether men or women experience higher rates of depression. It then reports on a demonstration project which sought to examine how critical incident analysis might be used as a form of assessment and as a supervisory tool by social work students and practice teachers. Whatever approach one takes, being critically reflective involves a number of key things (Brookfield, 1998), including: An analysis of our assumptions. A useful text for students of all levels with good examples. << Back to Understanding Academic Terms page. The article aims to provide a step-by-step description of how thematic analysis was applied in a study examining why men choose to undertake social work as an area of study. If you have not reset your password since 2017, please use the 'forgot password' link below to reset your password and access your SAGE online account. Please refer to our updated. There is evidence that more women are treated for mental health problems than men (National Statistics, 2014). The essay analyses theories underpinning and key elements of critical social work and its values. The paper "Critical Analysis of Social Work when Working with Children and Families" is a good example of a literature review on sociology. As the authors of this book suggest, critical thinking is a ‘sought after’ skill in social work practice, yet is something that can be difficult for students to conceptualise. Early critical theory is broadly Marxist. Performing a critical analysis does not necessarily involve finding fault with a work. Women who have been subjected to domestic violence by male partners are being assessed within this discourse, which takes little account of societal perspectives, which sustain injustices and power differentials. International Social Work 2012 55: 4, 473-487 Download Citation. Social policies and social work practices are increasingly influenced by attachment theory. Participants in the study came from the University of Concepción in Chile and the University of Quebec in Abitibi-Témiscamingue in Canada. Very helpful, well written with handy examples and ideas for excercises supporting development and understanding of critical thinking and analysis. Finally a reflective discussion of a case study drawn from my … Critical Analysis definition To critically analyse means to make a judgement about the quality of evidence and include when it can and can’t support your argument. During this time, I have published a series of articles in the British Journal of Social Work (Parton, 1979, 1981, 1986, 1994, 1998, 2000, 2003, 2008, 2011a; Butt and Parton, 2005) which have been central in developing these ideas where two analytic themes have continually reoccurred related to:One of my un… Key features include: This will support you right from the very beginning of your programme through to the end of your final placement and into practice. This highly practical guidebook will help you develop the critical and analytical skills essential to your successful social work education and evidence-informed, reflective practice. A Critical Analysis of the Social Work Intervention Process The term ‘empowerment’ is one which is used to designate the idea of giving control to an individual: if someone feels empowered, it means that they feel as though they can do something. Imagine that in the High Court, someone is being trailed for a serious crime – each table in this room has a part to play in ... Critical analysis skills for social workers A randomised trial was appropriate in this quantitative research as it is considered to be the gold standard in assessing the effects of an intervention on a sample (Jones, 2017). The tool below can be used on your own, in supervision or in a group to: Reflect on experiences of working with carers; Identify learning about good practice 3. Critical thinking can assist social workers in surfacing tacit knowledge, identifying areas in which they are well-informed, and clarifying areas where they need to increase their knowledge. This practical text is written in such a way, that it aims to speak directly to student social workers to help them understand the concept, and application of, critical thinking. A critical analysis examines an article or other work to determine how effective the piece makes an argument or point. Theoretical break down and simplification of key theories, Activities to help you cement your learning, Research Methods, Statistics & Evaluation. Question 1 (The current critical incident analysis model is about the dynamic interrelationship between the main components in the critical event. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders.

Leave a Reply